90s Winona Ryder Makeup: How to Get the Look
Not every version of 90s beauty was neon and dewy. There was another side entirely — pale, dramatic, and unapologetically dark, worn by the era’s alternative icons and immortalized by Winona Ryder in Beetlejuice and Heathers. That same gothic-glam aesthetic has resurfaced hard lately, thanks in part to Stranger Things’ 80s setting and its own moody cast, led in part by Winona Ryder herself. The 90s Winona Ryder makeup look has become a beauty staple again — instantly recognizable for its pale base, smoky eyes, and deep, vampy lip.
Affiliate & Advertising Disclosure: LumiVexa is a reader-supported publication. Product purchases made through links on this website may generate an affiliate commission from Amazon Associates at no additional expense to the buyer. For details, please review the formal Affiliate Disclosure and Privacy Policy.
Recreating this look starts with the base. Winona Ryder’s 90s makeup relied on a matte, almost porcelain complexion — a stark contrast to the bronzed, dewy looks that dominated the rest of the decade. A light-to-medium coverage foundation in a cool or neutral undertone, set with a translucent powder, gets you most of the way there without looking like stage makeup.
The eyes carry a lot of the drama. Think soft, smudged charcoal or deep brown shadow blended low and wide around the eye, paired with a defined but slightly imperfect liner — the goal is moody, not precise. A few coats of a volumizing black mascara finish the effect.
Then there’s the lip — arguably the most recognizable part of the whole look. A deep berry, oxblood, or near-black lipstick, often worn slightly matte, ties the whole face together and is what most people picture first when they think of this era’s alternative beauty aesthetic.
Key Elements Behind This Look
The dark 80s aesthetic runs on contrast and drama rather than glow — pale skin against near-black lips and heavily lined eyes is the whole point, not a side effect.
- ✦ Matte, pale-toned base — a cool-toned, matte foundation a shade or two lighter than your natural skin tone sets the stage; this look leans into porcelain rather than sun-kissed.
- ✦ Heavily lined, smoky eyes — thick black kohl liner smudged into a soft, undefined edge, often paired with dark grey or plum eyeshadow for extra depth.
- ✦ Dark, matte lip colour — black, deep plum, or oxblood lipstick, applied precisely with a lip liner for a clean, deliberate edge rather than a soft blur.
- ✦ Minimal blush or none at all — this look intentionally skips a warm flush; a cool-toned, barely-there contour works better than colour on the cheeks.
- ✦ Setting powder over gloss — a matte finish throughout is essential to the aesthetic, unlike the dewy glow of brighter 80s looks.
How to Recreate the Look
Prep & Prime
Start with a lightweight, matte-finish primer to keep your base from getting shiny throughout the day.
Build the Base
Apply a cool-toned foundation slightly lighter than your natural tone for porcelain-like coverage. Set immediately with translucent powder.
Skip the Warmth
Use a cool-toned, barely-there contour if desired, and omit blush entirely to keep the focus on the eyes and lips.
Smoky Eye Build
Apply charcoal or plum shadow wide around the eye. Smudge black kohl liner into the lash line and blend the edges softly.
Define the Lip
Line lips with a matching pencil for a clean edge, fill with a matte deep berry or near-black lipstick, and blot lightly.
Best time to try this: Halloween, themed parties, editorial-style photoshoots, or simply as a dramatic evening look for anyone drawn to a moodier aesthetic than most current beauty trends offer.
Formulas That Don’t Pair Well
Dewy, illuminating primers work directly against the matte, porcelain base this look depends on — save those for a different aesthetic entirely. Similarly, glossy or balm-based lip products won’t hold the sharp, defined edge dark lip colour needs here.
Heavy exfoliation or retinol the same morning can leave lips and skin more reactive than usual, making precise lip liner application and matte powder harder to set evenly. As with brighter looks, save actives for a nighttime routine instead.
Five Products Worth Trying
- Ultra-lightweight foundation in natural ivory
- Mattifies and refines pores and leaves a natural, seamless finish
- Formulated with micro-powders to control shine and blur pores
- Ideal for normal to oily skin
- No.1 Foundation in Canada
- Wonderskin 1440 Waterproof Eyeliner gives 24-hour stay-put wear and rich, high-intensity color. This smudge-proof, long-…
- Our waterproof eyeliner pencil delivers vibrant, high-impact color for 1440 minutes. Transfer-proof, budge-proof, and sm…
- TruGlide Technology ensures a tug-free, precise application. Sharpen to a fine tip for detailed lines or smudge within 3…
- Vegan, cruelty-free, and BHT-free, our long-wear eyeliner offers precision and comfort. Perfect for creating sharp lines…
- Feel confident that your eyeliner will stay put all day without any smudging or fading, making it the perfect choice for…
- Professional Gothic Color Palette: 15 highly pigmented, no-duplicate shades crafted for bold, dramatic looks. Features 6…
- Dazzling Multichrome & Glitter Finishes:This goth eyeshadow palette contains several unique shadows. Silver Explosion Gl…
- Versatile for Creative Play: This smokey eye makeup is ideal for face, body, and bold artistic expression. Elevate every…
- Vegan & Cruelty-Free Formula: 100% vegan, paraben-free, and microplastic-free. Ethical, skin-friendly makeup designed fo…
- Pro Application Tips: Use dense flat brushes, sponge applicators, or fingers to maximize shimmer/metallic payoff. Pair w…
- Dazzling Dual Effects: Experience the magic of Oulac metallic shine lipstick, with dense glitter creating two effects – …
- One Swipe Makeup: Achieve a high-pigmented lightweight sparkle finish with just a few simple swipes of metallic lipstick…
- Creamy Hydrating Formula: Indulge in the dreamy feel of Oulac Lipsticks infused with Coconut Oils and Castor Oil for a c…
- Luxurious Packaging: Glitter lipstick tube has a unique mirror design for on-the-go touch-ups and high-end magnetic hook…
- Vegan Beauty: Available in 27 Vegan lipstick shades, experience the perfect blend of comfort and style with creamy lipst…
- Baking powder makeup for all skin tones
- Fragrance-free and oil-free
- lightweight powder for oily skin and dry skin
- 16 hours of smudge and transfer-resistant wear
Aesthetic Breakdown & Comparison
| Product | Finish | Reviewer-Reported Wear Time | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pale Matte Foundation | Matte | ~8–10 hrs | Porcelain, cool-toned base |
| Black Kohl Eyeliner | Smudge-friendly matte | ~6–8 hrs | Heavy, smoky eye lining |
| Grey/Plum Eyeshadow Palette | Full matte | ~10+ hrs | Smoky crease depth |
| Matte Black/Oxblood Lipstick | Full matte | ~4–6 hrs | Statement dark lip |
| Mattifying Setting Powder | Full matte lock | Extends wear by ~2–3 hrs | Long-day/night wear |
Lumivexa’s Verdict
The dark, gothic side of 90s beauty is worth trying at least once, especially if the bright, dewy version of the trend never quite felt like “you.” Based on the research gathered here, this look rewards precision and patience more than the softer, more forgiving pop-color version — but the payoff is a genuinely dramatic, unforgettable finish.
Pros: Reviewers consistently describe it as striking and photo-ready, with a strong sense of character that stands out from most current, softer beauty trends.
Cons: Precise lip liner work and heavy eye smudging both take more practice than a quick, forgiving cream-blush routine, and pale foundation shades can be trickier to color-match for some skin tones.
Starting with just the eyes or just the lip before combining both is a good way to build confidence with this more dramatic technique gradually. A cotton swab dipped in makeup remover is the easiest way to clean up any smudged liner without redoing the whole eye.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is this the same as the Winona Ryder 90s look everyone’s searching for?
Yes, essentially — this dark, matte, high-contrast aesthetic is exactly the look most people mean when they search for a “Winona Ryder 90s” style, drawing directly from her iconic roles in Beetlejuice and Heathers and echoed more recently through Stranger Things’ 80s setting.
How is this different from the brighter, dewy 90s trend?
The two sit at opposite ends of 90s beauty. This look is matte, pale, and dramatic, while the brighter version leans into dewy skin and bold color, closer to a Madonna-style pop aesthetic. Check out our bright & dewy 90s look guide if that’s more your style.
Product photography mockups and promotional assets featured within this shopping list are sourced from official manufacturer catalogs or accessed via authorized Amazon Associates marketing channels.
Medical & Safety Disclaimer: The content featured on LumiVexa is for informational, aesthetic, and everyday entertainment purposes only. As a platform dedicated to beauty enthusiasm, content involves researching ingredient profiles, analyzing formulation catalogs, and identifying viral trends. Personal product testing is not performed, and operations are not conducted by a professional dermatologist, aesthetician, or medical provider. Because skin types react uniquely to different formulations, official manufacturer guidelines must always be reviewed, proper patch tests performed, and a certified health professional consulted before introducing any featured cosmetic or skincare product to a personal routine.